Bengaluru: Karnataka Food, Civil Supplies, Consumer Affairs and Legal Metrology Minister Rizwan Arshad has written to Union Petroleum and Natural Gas Minister Hardeep Singh Puri, placing the state’s findings on fuel quality and quantity before the Centre and urging a review of the E20 programme, according to the text of the letter released by his media team on Wednesday.
The Karnataka government is not against the Ethanol Blending Programme but against over-blending, the minister wrote, adding that the programme cannot come at the cost of citizens. A transition of this scale needs the whole ecosystem, including fuel infrastructure and ethanol-compliant vehicles, to be ready, and that takes time, he said.
Over the past several months the state has received a very large number of complaints from motorists, who reported falling mileage, rough running of engines, damage to older vehicles and receiving less fuel than they paid for, the letter said. Left unanswered, such complaints turn into a trust deficit between people and the fuel sold to them, it said, and the state therefore verified the quality and quantity of petrol through officers empowered under law.
On quality, the letter cites the Petroleum Ministry’s Notification S.O. 860(E) dated February 17, 2026, in force from April 1, 2026, which directs oil companies to sell ethanol-blended petrol with 20 per cent ethanol as per BIS specifications. Clauses 7 and 8 of the Motor Spirit and High Speed Diesel (Regulation of Supply, Distribution and Prevention of Malpractices) Order, 2005 empower state officers to inspect retail outlets and draw samples, it said.
In September 2026, state officers inspected 63 retail outlets covering IOCL, BPCL, HPCL and MRPL. The samples were first sent through the oil marketing companies’ (OMCs) State Level Coordinator to the designated laboratories of the three public sector OMCs, the letter said. Only 42 reports have been received so far, and none of them gives the percentage of ethanol in the sample.
When the state asked why, it was told that the Research Octane Number (RON) is the compliance parameter. The letter said the OMCs’ own reply acknowledges that IS 17021 mandates measuring ethanol content in blended petrol, yet no such measurement was carried out, which it called a clear admission of non-compliance with the standard they cite. A report silent on ethanol cannot certify compliance with an E20 mandate, it said. Reports for the remaining 21 samples are yet to arrive, with no reason given for the delay.
Not satisfied with these results, the state drew fresh samples and sent them to independent laboratories accredited by the National Accreditation Board for Testing and Calibration Laboratories (NABL). Of the 14 samples tested, 11 had more than 20 per cent ethanol, the highest at over 31 per cent, the letter said.
The OMCs have since contested the findings, alleging that the samples were not collected as per the prescribed procedure and questioning their density. The state rejected the allegations as baseless and factually incorrect, the letter said. Every sample was drawn by officers authorised under the 2005 Order, strictly following clause 8, with counterpart samples sealed and handed over on the spot. The density of each sample was recorded in the prescribed proforma at the point of collection and signed by dealers and other authorised representatives, and the densities reported by the laboratories match those recorded at the outlets, it said. To keep the process credible, the state did not use its own laboratories.
The letter said the OMCs kept back the one fact consumers needed to know and are now trying to discredit independent, accredited findings instead of answering them, calling it an attempt to avoid accountability.
Two further findings deserve attention, the letter said. First, the blend is not uniform: ethanol content across the samples ranged from 13.5 per cent to 31.2 per cent against the notified 20 per cent, leaving consumers unaware of the composition of the fuel going into their vehicles. Second, premium high-speed petrol, which consumers buy at nearly Rs 120 to Rs 140 a litre because it is marketed as a superior fuel, was also found to carry a high percentage of ethanol, leaving the common man with no real option.
The state’s inspections have created a sense of deterrence, and there are indications that the blend may since have been corrected, the letter said. But consumer protection cannot rest on the hope that one round of inspections has set matters right, it said. Karnataka will continue to check fuel quality at retail outlets on a continuous basis and act firmly wherever any deviation from the notified standard is found.
On the quantity of petrol, the letter said two recent Central notifications have weakened safeguards. Notification G.S.R. 905(E) dated December 18, 2025 doubles the mandatory verification interval for petrol and diesel dispensers from 12 months to 24 months, which means a faulty meter may go unchecked for up to two years. Notification G.S.R. 346(E) dated May 8, 2026 amends the rules on Government Approved Test Centres so that private test centres can verify petrol, diesel and other such dispensers, work that government inspectors have done so far.
Before adopting these changes, the state’s Legal Metrology Department carried out a state-wide inspection survey to test their scientific basis, which the letter described as the first such study by any state. Of Karnataka’s 5,946 retail outlets, 805 were inspected and 768, nearly nine in every ten, required recalibration. Of the 3,071 nozzles tested, 2,618 showed deviation from their rated accuracy. A total of 101 outlets dispensing beyond the maximum permissible error were booked, and fines of Rs 6.66 lakh were collected. Even nozzles within the permissible limit were nearing their tolerance threshold within 9 to 11 months of use, the letter said, so the existing annual cycle is itself barely adequate.
The state has therefore decided not to implement either notification and will continue annual verification of all dispensers through government inspectors, the letter said. As legal metrology comes under the Department of Consumer Affairs, the state has also written to Union Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution Minister Pralhad Joshi seeking reconsideration of both notifications, and Arshad asked that both ministries act together.
The minister listed five demands. The actual ethanol blend of each grade of petrol should be displayed prominently at every pump. The bill or receipt issued at the pump should record the ethanol percentage of the fuel sold. Until the vehicle fleet is fully compatible with higher blends, E10 and ethanol-free petrol should be available along with E20 at affordable cost. A third-party mechanism for random testing of fuel quality should be set up using NABL-accredited laboratories with no stake in the outcome, with every test report stating the ethanol content. And a dedicated E20 compensation fund should compensate consumers whose vehicles are damaged by petrol with ethanol above the prescribed limit, with claims settled through a simple, time-bound process on the basis of certification from authorised service centres.
The findings indicate that the E20 policy, as implemented today, requires urgent course correction, the letter said, and the policy can succeed only if the common man is at its centre and not made to bear its cost. The transition must be backed by incentives and support for upgrading cars and infrastructure at retail outlets, including dispensing units, storage and testing facilities, with adequate time for the upgrade, it said. It added that the findings must be treated above politics to protect the livelihoods and hard-earned money of ordinary citizens.
Arshad urged Puri to review the implementation of the E20 programme in consultation with the states. Karnataka has placed all its evidence before the Government of India and would welcome a detailed discussion at the earliest, so that together they can protect the people and restore public trust, the letter said.
The letter encloses the test reports received from OMC laboratories (42 of 63 samples) and the sampling proformas with recorded densities, along with test certificates from NABL-accredited laboratories, for the 14 samples.
Earlier, Arshad had sought independent E20 testing in response to Pralhad Joshi and the state had reported petrol tests finding up to 31.2 per cent ethanol.
