National Anthem Neglect Sparks Legal Row: High Court Issues Notice to Devanahalli School After Students File Petition
Dharwad: The Karnataka High Court on Thursday quashed the National Testing Agency’s (NTA) decision to withhold the NEET (UG) 2026 re-examination result of Anushka Basavaraj Maidur, a 20-year-old student from Ranibennur in Haveri district, over an allegation that she carried a mobile phone into the earlier exam that was later scrapped, and held that the seat she won on merit stands. A Division Bench of Justice M Nagaprasanna and Justice Hema Kulkarni at the Dharwad Bench allowed her petition in Ms. Anushka Basavaraj Maidur v. National Testing Agency & Others (W.P. No. 107041 of 2026).
According to the order, NEET (UG) 2026 held on May 3, 2026 was cancelled in its entirety after a widespread leak of question papers, and a re-examination was notified on May 15 for June 21. On June 17, three days after she was issued a fresh admit card, the NTA sent her a show-cause notice alleging that she had carried a mobile phone into the examination premises during the May 3 exam. She appeared in the June 21 re-examination. An Unfair Means Committee met on June 25, and when results were declared on July 16, hers alone was marked ‘result withheld’.
After her representations went unanswered, she moved the High Court seeking to quash the notice and the score card remark, release of her result and permission to take part in the medical counselling on her claimed score of 570 marks. On September 8, 2026 the court allowed her to participate in the counselling without claiming any equity. She has since taken a seat at the Belagavi Institute of Medical Sciences, her counsel told the court.
The petition named the NTA, the National Medical Commission, the Medical Counselling Committee, the State of Karnataka’s Department of Medical Education and the Karnataka Examinations Authority as respondents. Additional Solicitor General Arvind Kamath, for the NTA and the Medical Counselling Committee, argued that carrying a phone into the examination premises is categorically an unfair means practice whatever advantage is derived, and that withholding the result is the least penalty under the NEET (UG) 2026 Information Bulletin. He also argued that her later good performance cannot dilute the consequence.
The petitioner’s counsel argued that an unfair means allegation must have a rational link to an advantage in the exam concerned, and that an exam that has been scrapped cannot be revived to penalise her in an independent re-examination. The court said she had explained that she carried the phone inadvertently because of exam stress, and that mere possession of a phone, while a breach of instructions, cannot invariably be equated with using unfair means to secure an undeserved advantage.
The Bench said examination discipline is sacrosanct and merit obtained by malpractice is no merit in law, but this case was different: the exam in which the infraction was alleged had been scrapped, no advantage from it was carried forward, and no malpractice was alleged in the re-examination. “A cancelled examination may remain a matter of history”, it said, adding that it cannot become a perpetual impediment to a student’s future without sufficient legal justification.
The court allowed the petition and quashed the June 17, 2026 show-cause notice and the July 16, 2026 score card remark ‘RESULT WITHHELD/R/W’. It held that the seat secured by the petitioner on merit stands and directed the NTA to issue her marks card without any observation that her result was withheld or cancelled. All other impugned actions stand obliterated, the court said.
