Skip to content
The Bengaluru Live | Bengaluru News, Breaking Updates

The Bengaluru Live | Bengaluru News, Breaking Updates

Bengaluru’s Leading News Portal

Primary Menu
  • HOME
  • Bengaluru
  • Karnataka
  • POLITICS
  • CRIME
  • Delhi
  • Kannada News
  • Hindi News
  • MORE NEWS
    • Supreme Court
    • CITY UPDATES
    • PM
    • SPORTS
    • STATE
    • EDUCATION
    • ENTERTAINMENT
    • HEALTH
    • Real Estate
    • SPORTS
    • CORONA
    • MOBILITY/TRANSPORT
    • Horoscope
    • Submit a Press Release
  • Sponsored
  • Home
  • CITY UPDATES
  • SC sets aside Karnataka HC order quashing CBI case over illegal iron ore export
  • CITY UPDATES
  • STATE

SC sets aside Karnataka HC order quashing CBI case over illegal iron ore export

December 16, 2024 5:43 PM 4 minutes read
📘 Read this story in Kannada

New Delhi, Dec 16 (PTI) In a relief to the CBI, the Supreme Court on Monday set aside a judgement of the Karnataka High Court quashing a 2013 criminal case against a company and others in an alleged case of illegal iron ore export.

A bench comprising Chief Justice Sanjiv Khanna and Justice Sanjay Kumar asked the Dharwad bench of the Karnataka High Court to decide the case afresh on some counts except the amount of the alleged iron ore exported by M/S MSPL Limited and others.

“We have set aside the (HC) judgement. The parties are directed to appear before the high court on February 3, 2025,” the bench said, “we have not expressed any opinion on the merits of the case.” The bench was hearing about 11 appeals of the CBI against the December 12 judgement of Justice M Nagaprasanna of the high court.

The HC judge quashed the proceedings initiated by the CBI in the case related to the illegal export of iron ore and said the registration of the case and the filing of the chargesheet by the CBI against M/S MSPL Limited and others were contrary to law.

The high court said the apex court had empowered the CBI to investigate cases of export of over 50,000 metric tonne of iron ore without valid permits.

It noted the total quantity alleged in the chargesheet against the company was 39,480 metric tonne, below the threshold set by the apex court.

The high court held the CBI lacked jurisdiction to register the case or file the chargesheet, but said it did not mean that MSPL Limited could not be investigated.

The high court said the special investigating team constituted by the Karnataka Lokayukta was empowered to initiate proceedings for cases below the 50,000 metric tonne threshold, going by the Supreme Court’s directions.

It held since the CBI had no jurisdiction, all actions arising from the chargesheet, including the cognisance taken by the trial court, were invalid.

On the issue of the role of directors, the high court said their specific roles must be clearly established in the complaint, investigation, and chargesheet.

The directors cannot be arraigned as accused without clear evidence of their active involvement in the alleged illegality, it said.

The company and others were prosecuted before a trial court at Ankola, Uttara Kannada District in the case of the CBI registered on October 24, 2013.

The central probe agency filed its chargesheet in 2022, for offences punishable under Section 120B (criminal conspiracy) and sections 379 (theft), 411 (keeping stolen property), 420 (cheating) and 447 (criminal trespass) of the IPC.

The apex court on September 7, 2012, passed an order directing the CBI to conduct a preliminary investigation with respect to 50.79 lakh metric tonne of iron ore exported from January 01, 2009 to May 31, 2010 from Belekeri port by various companies/individuals or exporters who had exported iron ore over 50,000 metric tonne without valid permits.

The CBI lodged the FIR under the provisions of the IPC and the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act. Nine years after lodging the FIR, the CBI filed the chargesheet against the firm and others on February 1, 2022.

The high court observed the apex court had clearly indicated that the CBI would step in only if the export by an individual or company would be more than 50,000 metric tonne.

“What would unmistakably emerge is, (i) in cases where exporters who have exported more than 50,000 metric tonnes without valid permits the CBI would get jurisdiction to register crimes and (ii) in cases where export is less than 50,000 metric tonne, Government of Karnataka has to take further action in accordance with law..,” it said.

The HC order therefore partly allowed the petition and quashed the chargesheet. PTI SJK AMK

About the Author

View All Posts

Post navigation

Previous: Gross leasing of office space set to rise 14 pc in 2024 to record 85 mn sq ft: Cushman & Wakefield
Next: Inventurus Knowledge Solutions IPO receives 52.68 times subscription

Related Stories

Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar offering flowers at a garlanded portrait of Basavanna beside a marigold-decked structure
  • STATE

FIR Registered Against Author Ravi Hanj Over Basavamantapa Book After Cabinet Discussion, Says CM Shivakumar, Warns of Strict Legal Action

The Bengaluru Live November 20, 2026 3:35 PM
KEA Executive Director H. Prasanna seated at his desk in front of the Karnataka Examinations Authority name and logo
  • STATE

KEA to Hold Counselling for Two-Year B.Ed Admissions for the First Time as Per Government Order, Online Applications Open Till November 30

The Bengaluru Live November 20, 2026 3:04 PM
Side-by-side portraits of Shivananda S Patil in a white kurta and Basanagouda Patil Yatnal in a saffron scarf with a tilak
  • STATE

Karnataka High Court Dismisses MLA Yatnal’s Plea Against Defamation Case, Says Complainant Need Not Always Examine Witness on Loss of Reputation

The Bengaluru Live November 20, 2026 11:08 AM

Latest Post

CM Shivakumar Meets Nandan Nilekani-Led High-Powered Committee on Examination Reforms at Vidhana Soudha Chief Minister and officials seated around a long wooden table in a committee room with the Karnataka Government emblem on the wall

CM Shivakumar Meets Nandan Nilekani-Led High-Powered Committee on Examination Reforms at Vidhana Soudha

November 20, 2026 4:36 PM
Karnataka High Court Rejects Housing Board’s Appeal Filed After 1,300-Day Delay Against Reinstatement of Dismissed Engineer Front view of the High Court of Karnataka building in Bengaluru
  • Karnataka

Karnataka High Court Rejects Housing Board’s Appeal Filed After 1,300-Day Delay Against Reinstatement of Dismissed Engineer

November 20, 2026 4:10 PM
Books Give Direction to Our Thoughts and Guide Society, Governor Sudha Yadav Says at Veeraloka’s 6th Book Santhe in Jayanagar A woman in a saree cutting a yellow ribbon with scissors at the inauguration of a book fair, with officials and organisers around her

Books Give Direction to Our Thoughts and Guide Society, Governor Sudha Yadav Says at Veeraloka’s 6th Book Santhe in Jayanagar

November 20, 2026 3:38 PM
FIR Registered Against Author Ravi Hanj Over Basavamantapa Book After Cabinet Discussion, Says CM Shivakumar, Warns of Strict Legal Action Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar offering flowers at a garlanded portrait of Basavanna beside a marigold-decked structure
  • STATE

FIR Registered Against Author Ravi Hanj Over Basavamantapa Book After Cabinet Discussion, Says CM Shivakumar, Warns of Strict Legal Action

November 20, 2026 3:35 PM
KEA to Hold Counselling for Two-Year B.Ed Admissions for the First Time as Per Government Order, Online Applications Open Till November 30 KEA Executive Director H. Prasanna seated at his desk in front of the Karnataka Examinations Authority name and logo
  • STATE

KEA to Hold Counselling for Two-Year B.Ed Admissions for the First Time as Per Government Order, Online Applications Open Till November 30

November 20, 2026 3:04 PM
Karnataka High Court Says Aided Schools Still Need Prior Permission to Fill Vacancies, but Govt Cannot Reject Requests Only on 2015 Cut-Off Front view of the High Court of Karnataka building in Bengaluru
  • Karnataka

Karnataka High Court Says Aided Schools Still Need Prior Permission to Fill Vacancies, but Govt Cannot Reject Requests Only on 2015 Cut-Off

November 20, 2026 3:03 PM

You may have missed

Chief Minister and officials seated around a long wooden table in a committee room with the Karnataka Government emblem on the wall

CM Shivakumar Meets Nandan Nilekani-Led High-Powered Committee on Examination Reforms at Vidhana Soudha

The Bengaluru Live November 20, 2026 4:36 PM
Front view of the High Court of Karnataka building in Bengaluru
  • Karnataka

Karnataka High Court Rejects Housing Board’s Appeal Filed After 1,300-Day Delay Against Reinstatement of Dismissed Engineer

The Bengaluru Live November 20, 2026 4:10 PM
A woman in a saree cutting a yellow ribbon with scissors at the inauguration of a book fair, with officials and organisers around her

Books Give Direction to Our Thoughts and Guide Society, Governor Sudha Yadav Says at Veeraloka’s 6th Book Santhe in Jayanagar

The Bengaluru Live November 20, 2026 3:38 PM
Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar offering flowers at a garlanded portrait of Basavanna beside a marigold-decked structure
  • STATE

FIR Registered Against Author Ravi Hanj Over Basavamantapa Book After Cabinet Discussion, Says CM Shivakumar, Warns of Strict Legal Action

The Bengaluru Live November 20, 2026 3:35 PM

About us

The Bengaluru Live is an independent digital news publication focused on Bengaluru and Karnataka, publishing news and information in English and Kannada since February 2020.

Useful Links

  • About The Bengaluru Live
  • Contact Us
  • Editorial Standards & Corrections Policy
  • Publisher, Editorial Responsibility & Grievance
  • Ownership & Funding Transparency
  • Advertise with us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Submit a Press Release

Recent News

  • CM Shivakumar Meets Nandan Nilekani-Led High-Powered Committee on Examination Reforms at Vidhana Soudha
  • Karnataka High Court Rejects Housing Board’s Appeal Filed After 1,300-Day Delay Against Reinstatement of Dismissed Engineer
  • Books Give Direction to Our Thoughts and Guide Society, Governor Sudha Yadav Says at Veeraloka’s 6th Book Santhe in Jayanagar
  • FIR Registered Against Author Ravi Hanj Over Basavamantapa Book After Cabinet Discussion, Says CM Shivakumar, Warns of Strict Legal Action
©Copyright 2026 The Bengaluru Live All rights reserved. | MoreNews by AF themes.