The High Court of Karnataka in Bengaluru. Image: High Court of Karnataka
Bengaluru: The Karnataka High Court has held that aided primary and secondary schools in the state must continue to obtain the competent authority’s prior permission before filling vacancies, but that the State cannot reject such requests only because the vacancy arose after December 31, 2015, or by mechanically relying on a February 2023 letter. A Division Bench ruled on Tuesday in Writ Appeal No. 361 of 2024, allowing the State’s appeal in part.
The Bench of Justice D K Singh and Justice H Shanthi Bhushan set aside part of a single judge’s order of December 8, 2023, which had read the prior-permission rule as a mere requirement to inform the authority, leaving it only to check that the reservation roster was followed. The Bench declared that prior permission continues to operate and that the authority may examine all relevant statutory requirements before granting or refusing it. Justice D K Singh authored the judgment.
The writ petition had been filed by the Karnataka Rajya Anudanitha Shikshana Samsthegala Okkuta, a society of aided schools. The Bench held that the society could not seek permission on behalf of its member institutions, and that each aided institution, through its management or the competent authority, must apply individually.
The Bench said the State’s June 10, 2020 notification restricting the filling of vacancies cannot be read as a perpetual ban, because the restriction was confined to the financial year 2020-21, when the Covid-19 pandemic had strained finances. It also held that the letter of February 2, 2023 is not by itself a government policy or statutory instrument imposing a blanket ban on filling vacancies that arose after December 31, 2015, and that the cut-off date cannot be applied mechanically without an identifiable government decision and a rational basis.
On each application, the competent authority must decide independently, looking at the sanctioned posts, the date and nature of the vacancy, existing teaching and student strength, the staffing pattern and the reservation roster, and must also examine whether leaving the post vacant would push the institution below the prescribed staffing requirements. The decision must be taken within two months of receiving the application, and any refusal must be supported by reasons and communicated to the institution.
The court clarified that its directions do not give any institution an automatic right to fill a vacancy or to claim grant-in-aid for an appointment, and that it is not directing the State to sanction grant-in-aid for any particular post. The State remains free to frame a grant-in-aid policy considering its finances, provided the policy is consistent with the Act, the Rules and the Constitution.
