Skip to content
The Bengaluru Live | Bengaluru News, Breaking Updates

The Bengaluru Live | Bengaluru News, Breaking Updates

Bengaluru’s Leading News Portal

Primary Menu
  • HOME
  • Bengaluru
  • Karnataka
  • POLITICS
  • CRIME
  • Delhi
  • Kannada News
  • Hindi News
  • MORE NEWS
    • Supreme Court
    • CITY UPDATES
    • PM
    • SPORTS
    • STATE
    • EDUCATION
    • ENTERTAINMENT
    • HEALTH
    • Real Estate
    • SPORTS
    • CORONA
    • MOBILITY/TRANSPORT
    • Horoscope
    • Submit a Press Release
  • Sponsored
  • Home
  • Uncategorised
  • Challenge to sedition law referred to larger bench by Supreme Court
  • Uncategorised

Challenge to sedition law referred to larger bench by Supreme Court

September 12, 2023 2:26 PM 5 minutes read
📘 Read this story in Kannada

NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court on Tuesday referred a batch of pleas challenging Section 124A of the Indian Penal Code which criminalizes the offence of sedition, to a Constitution bench of at least five judges.

A bench of Chief Justice of India DY Chandrachud and Justices JB Pardiwala and Manoj Misra declined the Centre’s request to defer examining the validity of the sedition law as the new Bill (Bharathiya Nyaya Samhita) is pending consideration before a standing committee of Parliament.

A three-judge bench headed by CJI said that even if the new Bill becomes a law, the past cases under Section 124A IPC will not be affected as the new penal law can only apply prospectively.

Therefore, the new law will not obviate the need for a constitutional adjudication on the validity of the provision, the top court said in the order.

The apex court said the reference of challenge to sedition law to a larger bench was needed as the provision was upheld by a five-judge bench in the 1962 judgment Kedar Nath Singh case.

It said, “In our view, the appropriate course is to direct the papers to be placed before the Chief Justice of India to consider that the batch of cases can be heard by a bench of at least five judges. We direct the Registry to place the papers before the Chief Justice of India so that an appropriate decision can be taken on an administrative side to form a bench of at least five judges.”

Senior advocate Kapil Sibal appearing for petitioners objected to the Centre’s request to defer the hearing since the new Bill is pending before the Parliamentary committee, saying the new Bill has a similar provision, which is “far worse”.

CJI told Attorney General R Venkataramani that even if the new Bill becomes a law, it can apply only prospectively and the past cases will be prosecuted as per the IPC, therefore, the challenge to Section 124A IPC will continue to be relevant regardless of the new law.

Earlier, the Supreme Court had ordered that sedition law will be kept in abeyance till the government’s exercise of reviewing the law is complete.

It had asked the Central government and States not to register any cases under Section 124A.

It had added that if such cases are registered in future, the parties are at liberty to approach court and the court has to expeditiously dispose of the same.

Allowing the Central government to re-examine and reconsider the provisions of Section 124A, the apex court had said that it would be appropriate not to use the provision of law till further re-examination is over.

Earlier, the Centre had told the top court that the government cannot prevent police from registering a cognisable offence under the sedition provision, but an FIR under Section 124A would be registered only if the area Superintendent of Police (SP) is satisfied that the facts of a case involve sedition offence.

Senior advocate Kapil Sibal appearing for petitioners had told the bench that the then Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru had termed Section 124A as the most obnoxious provision aimed at stiffling dissent and Mahatma Gandhi had termed this as the most potent weapon to silence opposition to government.

Centre had then replied that this government was trying to do what Pandit Nehru could not do then.

In the affidavit, the Centre had said that Prime Minister Narendra Modi is of the firm view that the baggage of colonial-era laws, which outlived their utility, must be scrapped during the period of ‘Azadi Ka Marti Mahotsav’ (75 years of independence).

In that spirit, the government of India has scrapped over 1,500 outdated laws since 2014-15, it had stated.

However, before that the Central government took a stand that the 1962 verdict of the five-judge Constitution bench case which upheld the validity of the offence of sedition under Section 124A of the Indian Penal Code, is binding and continues to be a “good law and needs no reconsideration”.

It had said that the 1962 five-judge bench judgement of the top court in the Kedar Nath Singh v/s State of Bihar case which upheld the validity of Section 124A of IPC has stood the test of time and applied to date in tune with modern constitutional principles.

Various petitions were filed in the apex court challenging the constitutional validity of sedition law. The pleas were filed by former army officer Major-General SG Vombatkere (Retd), former Union minister Arun Shourie, NGO PUCL, Editors Guild of India, Journalists Patricia Mukhim, Anuradha Bhasin, Manipur-based journalist Kishorechandra Wangkhemcha and Kanhaiya Lal Shukla from Chhattisgarh.

The then CJI NV Ramana had questioned the Central government on the requirement of sedition law even after 75 years of independence and observed that it was colonial law that was used against freedom fighters.

While pointing out that sedition law was used against freedom fighters like Mahatma Gandhi and Bal Gangadhar Tilak, the apex court had asked the Centre, why it couldn’t be repealed. It observed that the Centre has repealed many stale laws and enquired why the government is not looking into repealing Section 124A of the IPC.

It further said that the court was concerned about the misuse of such laws.

CJI had said, “use of sedition is like giving a saw to the carpenter to cut a piece of wood and he uses it to cut the entire forest itself”. Section 124-A (sedition) under the IPC is a non-bailable provision. (ANI)

About the Author

View All Posts

Post navigation

Previous: Technical issue with plane resolved, Justin Trudeau expected to depart for Canada today
Next: Ethan Hawke traveled in bus to attend premiere of his film ‘Wildcat’

Related Stories

  • Uncategorised

Reject BJP, RSS that divides society in name of caste and opposes Constitution: Siddaramaiah

January 28, 2024 7:27 PM
  • Uncategorised

Karnataka: BJP takes on Congress govt over Mandya flag hoisting issue

January 28, 2024 5:27 PM
  • Uncategorised

Karnataka village tense after Hanuman flag removed; police use force to quell unrest

January 28, 2024 5:27 PM

Latest Post

Governor Sudha Yadav Calls for Collective Effort to Build a Developed Karnataka at Lok Bhavan Kannada Rajyotsava Celebration With Special Children Children in yellow and red costumes form a human pyramid on stage in front of a Kannada Rajyotsava celebration banner

Governor Sudha Yadav Calls for Collective Effort to Build a Developed Karnataka at Lok Bhavan Kannada Rajyotsava Celebration With Special Children

November 20, 2026 12:34 AM
Karnataka Sets Up Praja Seva Commissionerate; Sakala Mission Additional Director Post Renamed Commissioner, Praja Seva Department First page of a Government of Karnataka order titled Establishment of a new Praja Seva Commissionerate in the State

Karnataka Sets Up Praja Seva Commissionerate; Sakala Mission Additional Director Post Renamed Commissioner, Praja Seva Department

November 19, 2026 11:37 PM
CM Shivakumar Hands Appointment Orders to New Government College Principals, Says Colleges Must Be Free of Religion, Caste and Hatred Chief Minister D K Shivakumar standing with other dignitaries on a stage under a Shaikshanika Sarathya banner

CM Shivakumar Hands Appointment Orders to New Government College Principals, Says Colleges Must Be Free of Religion, Caste and Hatred

November 19, 2026 9:36 PM
Special Summary Revision: Bengaluru North Corporation Discusses Common Polling Stations for Households at Meeting With Political Parties Officials seated at a table during a meeting with political party representatives

Special Summary Revision: Bengaluru North Corporation Discusses Common Polling Stations for Households at Meeting With Political Parties

November 19, 2026 9:14 PM
Bengaluru Tech Summit 2026 Ends With ₹1,050 Crore DeepTech Investment Announcements From 24 VCs; Karnataka Has 51% of India’s GCCs, Report Says Rows of delegates seated on sofas and chairs in a large exhibition hall with banners overhead

Bengaluru Tech Summit 2026 Ends With ₹1,050 Crore DeepTech Investment Announcements From 24 VCs; Karnataka Has 51% of India’s GCCs, Report Says

November 19, 2026 8:54 PM
Government Approves ₹2,321 Crore for White Topping 88 Bengaluru Roads in Fourth Phase; ₹487 Crore for Central Silk Board to K R Pura ORR Officials stand on a stretch of road under construction during an inspection of white topping work
  • STATE

Government Approves ₹2,321 Crore for White Topping 88 Bengaluru Roads in Fourth Phase; ₹487 Crore for Central Silk Board to K R Pura ORR

November 19, 2026 8:37 PM

You may have missed

Children in yellow and red costumes form a human pyramid on stage in front of a Kannada Rajyotsava celebration banner

Governor Sudha Yadav Calls for Collective Effort to Build a Developed Karnataka at Lok Bhavan Kannada Rajyotsava Celebration With Special Children

The Bengaluru Live November 20, 2026 12:34 AM
First page of a Government of Karnataka order titled Establishment of a new Praja Seva Commissionerate in the State

Karnataka Sets Up Praja Seva Commissionerate; Sakala Mission Additional Director Post Renamed Commissioner, Praja Seva Department

The Bengaluru Live November 19, 2026 11:37 PM
Chief Minister D K Shivakumar standing with other dignitaries on a stage under a Shaikshanika Sarathya banner

CM Shivakumar Hands Appointment Orders to New Government College Principals, Says Colleges Must Be Free of Religion, Caste and Hatred

The Bengaluru Live November 19, 2026 9:36 PM
Officials seated at a table during a meeting with political party representatives

Special Summary Revision: Bengaluru North Corporation Discusses Common Polling Stations for Households at Meeting With Political Parties

The Bengaluru Live November 19, 2026 9:14 PM

About us

The Bengaluru Live is an independent digital news publication focused on Bengaluru and Karnataka, publishing news and information in English and Kannada since February 2020.

Useful Links

  • About The Bengaluru Live
  • Contact Us
  • Editorial Standards & Corrections Policy
  • Publisher, Editorial Responsibility & Grievance
  • Ownership & Funding Transparency
  • Advertise with us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Submit a Press Release

Recent News

  • Governor Sudha Yadav Calls for Collective Effort to Build a Developed Karnataka at Lok Bhavan Kannada Rajyotsava Celebration With Special Children
  • Karnataka Sets Up Praja Seva Commissionerate; Sakala Mission Additional Director Post Renamed Commissioner, Praja Seva Department
  • CM Shivakumar Hands Appointment Orders to New Government College Principals, Says Colleges Must Be Free of Religion, Caste and Hatred
  • Special Summary Revision: Bengaluru North Corporation Discusses Common Polling Stations for Households at Meeting With Political Parties
©Copyright 2026 The Bengaluru Live All rights reserved. | MoreNews by AF themes.