Bengaluru: In a significant development, the Supreme Court has upheld a Karnataka High Court order staying summons issued by the Enforcement Directorate (ED) against Chief Minister Siddaramaiah’s wife Parvathi Siddaramaiah and Minister Bhairati Suresh in connection with the alleged MUDA land allotment scam. The verdict brings immediate relief to the CM’s family and halts ED’s probe temporarily.
However, political analysts believe the apex court’s decision offers only a short-term shield to the Chief Minister’s family. The next legal twist may come from Krishnamayi Krishna, the original complainant, who has challenged the earlier closure report (B-report) submitted in the MUDA case. If the court rejects the B-report, it could pave the way for the case to be reopened — potentially reigniting the investigation into alleged irregularities in 14 site allocations.
The Supreme Court’s remarks are being closely examined by legal and political circles. The court once again flagged concerns over the ED’s overreach and frequent political misuse. Notably, the ED’s premise of “proceeds of crime” was weakened after the 14 sites in question were voluntarily returned by the CM’s family, negating the charge of money laundering.
Meanwhile, the Congress party has seized on the court’s observation to accuse the BJP-led Centre of weaponizing central agencies for political vendetta. At the same time, BJP leaders, including MLA Dr. Ashwath Narayan, have claimed that the relief is not an exoneration but only a technical pause in the legal process. “This is no clean chit,” he said, calling the MUDA case a black mark on the CM’s record.
Adding to the suspense, a separate petition filed by Krishnamayi Krishna in the High Court seeks to transfer the case to the CBI, arguing for an independent probe. If granted, the case could begin afresh under a different agency. With the matter pending in court and the possibility of a renewed legal battle, the controversy is far from over.
As the legal dust settles, all eyes are now on two key questions — will the court reopen the MUDA case by rejecting the B-report, and will the CBI be formally roped in to investigate Karnataka’s most politically sensitive land scam?
